Blog

You are here: Home » Blog » Quality & Technical » Softwood vs Hardwood Pulp for Tissue: NBSK vs BHKP Fiber Comparison

Softwood vs Hardwood Pulp for Tissue: NBSK vs BHKP Fiber Comparison

Views: 0     Author: Site Editor     Publish Time: 2026-11-12      Origin: Site

Inquire

facebook sharing button
twitter sharing button
line sharing button
wechat sharing button
linkedin sharing button
pinterest sharing button
whatsapp sharing button
kakao sharing button
snapchat sharing button
telegram sharing button
sharethis sharing button

Softwood vs Hardwood Pulp for Tissue: NBSK vs BHKP Fiber Comparison

Softwood pulp is made from long-fibre conifers (pine, spruce) and gives tissue its tensile, tear and wet-web strength, while hardwood pulp is made from short-fibre trees (eucalyptus, birch) and gives softness, smoothness, opacity and absorption. Softwood fibres are roughly 2.5–3.8 mm long; hardwood fibres are only 0.7–1.2 mm. Tissue mills rarely use one alone — they blend the two, commonly with a long-fibre fraction of about 25–40%, to balance strength against the soft hand feel consumers want.

Softwood vs Hardwood at a Glance

Factor

Softwood pulp

Hardwood pulp

Common grades

NBSK (Northern Bleached Softwood Kraft)

BHKP (Bleached Hardwood Kraft)

Tree species

Pine, spruce, fir

Eucalyptus, birch, beech, acacia

Fibre length

About 2.5–3.8 mm (long)

About 0.7–1.2 mm (short)

Main contribution

Tensile, tear, wet-web strength, runability

Softness, smoothness, formation, opacity, absorption, bulk

Sheet character

Strong, resilient, can feel coarser

Soft, fine, uniform, gentle on skin

Typical role

Strength backbone

Filler and softness provider

Why Fibre Length Controls Performance

The difference starts with fibre morphology. A long softwood fibre has more contact area and forms more inter-fibre bonds, so it carries load across the web. This is what lets a parent roll survive high-speed unwinding, embossing and rewinding without breaking.

Short hardwood fibres pack more uniformly, producing an even formation with a smooth, soft surface and good opacity. They also support absorbency and bulk, which matter for facial tissue and towels. Used alone, however, short fibres do not build enough strength for a fast converting line.

NBSK and BHKP Explained

  • NBSK (Northern Bleached Softwood Kraft) is the benchmark long-fibre pulp. Its strong, durable fibres are the strength component in premium tissue and are valued for wet-web strength.

  • BHKP (Bleached Hardwood Kraft) is the short-fibre workhorse. Eucalyptus BHKP is widely used for its softness and uniform formation; birch is noted for relatively high strength. Research comparing hardwood species reports that birch can deliver higher dry and wet tensile strength than eucalyptus or beech, even though all three are short-fibre pulps.

How Mills Blend Softwood and Hardwood

A tissue furnish is engineered to hit both a strength target and a softness target. The exact ratio depends on the product and the creping process.

End product

Typical balance

Reason

Toilet tissue

Higher hardwood, softwood around 25–35%

Softness and bulk with enough run strength

Facial tissue

Mostly hardwood, softwood around 25–35%

Gentle feel, smooth surface, low lint

Napkin

Moderate softwood, around 30–40%

Needs fold stiffness and tear resistance

Kitchen / hardwound towel

Higher softwood, often 35–50%+

Wet strength and toughness for wet use

Increasing the softwood fraction raises tensile and tear strength (ISO 12625-4/5) but can make the sheet feel firmer and reduce bulk. Increasing hardwood improves softness and formation but lowers the strength margin. Refining and creping are then used to fine-tune the balance without changing the furnish.

How Pulp Choice Affects Finished Tissue Properties

  • Strength and runability: driven mainly by long softwood fibres; critical for avoiding web breaks.

  • Softness and hand feel: driven mainly by short hardwood fibres and the crepe ratio.

  • Opacity and appearance: short fibres improve formation and opacity (ISO 12625-16).

  • Absorbency: hardwood fibres and sheet bulk support water uptake (ISO 12625-8).

  • Sustainability: both can be sourced as FSC-certified virgin pulp; recycled and bamboo are separate alternatives.

HUAXIN Pulp and Specifications

HUAXIN supplies virgin-wood parent and jumbo reels using controlled softwood/hardwood furnishes, with width 200–2850 mm, GSM 11–42 g/m², diameter up to 1150 mm and a 76 mm (3 in) core. GSM by product: toilet 14–22, facial 14–18, napkin 16–22 and kitchen 32–40 g/m². Reels are tested against ISO 12625 Parts 3–8, with moisture held at 4–7%. A full container holds about 26 reels / 12–13 tons.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is stronger, softwood or hardwood pulp? Softwood pulp is stronger. Its long fibres (about 2.5–3.8 mm) create more inter-fibre bonds, giving higher tensile, tear and wet-web strength. Hardwood's short fibres (0.7–1.2 mm) prioritise softness and formation instead.

Why is hardwood pulp used in facial tissue? Hardwood fibres are short and fine, so they produce a soft, smooth, uniform sheet with good opacity and low lint — exactly the gentle feel facial tissue needs. A share of softwood is still added for line strength.

What is the typical softwood-to-hardwood ratio in tissue? It varies by product, but a long-fibre (softwood) share of roughly 25–40% is common. Towels use more softwood for wet strength, while facial and toilet tissue use more hardwood for softness.

What is the difference between NBSK and BHKP? NBSK is bleached softwood kraft pulp with long, strong fibres that provide strength. BHKP is bleached hardwood kraft pulp with short fibres that provide softness and smoothness. Most tissue is a blend of the two.

Table of Content list
Huaxin Global Co., Ltd. mainly produces toilet paper, facial tissue, napkins, towel rolls and finished products.

Quick Links

Contact Us

  +86-13599169075
   +8613599169075
  Jinzhu Building, Quan'an Road, Quanzhou City, Fujian Province, China
Send Us A Message
Copyright © 2025 Huaxin Global Co., Ltd. All rights reserved. Sitemap Privacy Policy